Skip to content

Welcome to North Devon Council


Application Number

53329

Status

Decision Approved


Sign up to notifications on this planning application Back to search results New search


Planning Online Status


  • Application
    Valid
    23/02/2012
  • Consultation
    End
    23/03/2012
  • Committee
    Meeting
    N/A
  • Decision

    FULL PLANNING + S106 APPROVAL
  • Decision
    Date
    10/10/2012
  • Appeal
    Started
    N/A
  • Appeal
    Decision
    N/A
Summary
Application Number 53329
Location Address Land at Pill Gardens Braunton Devon
Proposal DEMOLITION OF 32 PREFABRICATED DWELLINGS & ERECTION OF 62 DWELLINGS TOGETHER WITH ASSOCIATED PARKING & AMENITY AREAS
Status FULL PLANNING + S106 APPROVAL
Application Type Full Application
Appeal Decision N/A

Important Dates
Application Received Date 23/02/2012
Application Valid Date 23/02/2012
Consultation Start Date 29/02/2012
Site Visited / Site Notice Date
Consultation End 23/03/2012
Advert Expiry 22/03/2012
Committee Date (if applicable)
Committee Agenda
Expiry Date 24/05/2012
Decision Date 10/10/2012

Further Information
Expected Decision Level Delegated
Case Officer Mr R. Pedlar
Parish BRAUNTON
Ward BRAUNTON EAST
Applicant Name NORTH DEVON HOMES LTD
Agent Name TREWIN DESIGN PARTNERSHIP
Agent Address 1 STANHOPE SQUARE, HOLSWORTHY, EX226DR

Copyright Notice

Plans, drawings and material submitted to the council are protected by the copyright acts (section 47, 1988 act). You may only use material which is downloaded and/or printed for consultation purposes, to compare current applications with previous schemes and to check whether developments have been completed in accordance with approved plans. Further copies must not be made without the prior permission of the copyright owner.

Tick here to show you have read and agree with the Copyright Notice.

Document Download Tips

  • To download documents, tick the boxes relating to the documents you wish to view and click the Download Selected Files button.
  • If you wish to download ALL documents place a tick in the box in the header row and this will select all files in the grid.
  • Note: some devices such as iPads that use iOS browsers do not have the standard capability to download multiple files as a default function. If you are experiencing difficulties you may need to download a free application to enable you to extract from zip files.
File Date Description File Size Drawing/Rev Number
Decision Notice
Decision Notice 10/10/2012 #DECISIONNOTICE# (0kb) -
Decision Summary 10/10/2012 #DECISIONSUMMARY# (0kb) -
Section 106 Information
Section 106 Legal Agreement 10/10/2012 Signed Agreement redacted (0kb) -
Planning Application Documents
53329_CR_POS_120809.pdf 09/08/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_Amended_Landscaping-Strategy_120517.pdf 21/05/2012 #PLAN3# (0kb) -
53329_Waste-Audit_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Sustainability-Renewal-Energy-Statement_120223.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Location-Plan-Block-Plan_111223.pdf 29/02/2012 #MAP#3 (0kb) -
53329_Highway-Adoption-Proposed_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Flood-Risk-Assessment_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Plots-21-26_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Floor-Plans-Plots-16-18_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_CR_Landscape_120723.pdf 23/07/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_Highways_120629.pdf 03/07/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_POS_120614.pdf 14/06/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_HousingOfficer_120420.pdf 23/04/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_Transport-Statement_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Statement-of-Consultation-with-PCT_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Site-Plan-120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #MAP# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Plots-46-49_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Plots-27-31_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-53-54_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-53-54_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-19-20_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevation-Floor-Shed_120220.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Design-and-Access-Statement_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Landscape-Strategy_120517.pdf 21/05/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Travel-Plan_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Sustainability_Pre-Assessment-Estimator_120223.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Invitation_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Site-Plan-and-Drainage_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #MAP# (0kb) -
53329_Sections_Housetypes-4-5-6-7_120220.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_SE_Plots-57-62_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Plots-32-36_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-55-56_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-55-56_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-37-38_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-6-7_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Draft-S106_120223.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Application-Form_111223.pdf 29/02/2012 #APPFORM# (0kb) -
53329_CR_EnvHealth_120709.pdf 10/07/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_Sustainability_120628.pdf 28/06/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_BrauntonPC_120315.pdf 15/03/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_Newsletter-December-2011_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Site-Survey_111223.pdf 29/02/2012 #MAP# (0kb) -
53329_Sections_Housetypes-7-8-9_120220.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_NW-Plots-57-62_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Floor-Plans-Plots-46-49_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Floor-Plans-Plots-27-31_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Arboriculture-Impact-Assessment_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_CR_Sustainability_120710.pdf 10/07/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_Highways_120418.pdf 23/04/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_COR_Trewin_140425.pdf 24/06/2014 #CORRE# (0kb) -
53329_Sections_Housetypes-1-2-3_120220.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Road-Safety-Audit_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Highway-Plan-1_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Foul-Drainage-Assessment_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Floor-Plans-Plots-8-10_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors-Plot-5_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plot-2_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Affordable-Housing-Statement_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_CR_Sustainability_120622.pdf 25/06/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_Amended_Location-Layout-Proposed_120418.pdf 18/04/2012 #PLAN3# (0kb) -
53329_Tree-Survey_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN1# (0kb) -
53329_Sustainability-Percentage-Renewables_120223.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Newsletter-September-2011_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Statement-of-Community-Involvement_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Sections-Site-Plan_120220.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Highway-Plan-2_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Highway-Adoption-Existing_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Floor-Plans-Plots-21-26_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Plots-8-10_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plot-3_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-50-52_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-42-43_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-11-13_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Ecological-Appraisal_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Landscaping-Strategy_120416.pdf 18/04/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_CR_EnvAgency_120313.pdf 13/03/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_PoliceLiaison_120313.pdf 13/03/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_SWW_120306.pdf 08/03/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_CR_NatEngland_120306.pdf 07/03/2012 #CONS# (0kb) -
53329_Prelimi-Geotechnical-Contamination-Investigation_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Highway-Plan-3_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Floor-Plans-Plots-57-62_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Floor-Plans-Plots-32-36_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Plots-16-18-120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors-Plot-4_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors-Plot-1_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-44-45_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Elevations-Floors_Plots-14-15_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #PLAN2# (0kb) -
53329_Ecological-Assessment_120125.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -
53329_Crime-and-Disorder-Statement_120223.pdf 29/02/2012 #SUPDOC# (0kb) -

Consultation Responses

Neighbour List


In addition to consultations with the consultee listed, we will publicise the application in accordance with national requirements and our local policy. This publicity usually takes the form of letters to nearby properties, the posting of site notices and/or the placing of a public notice in our local newspapers.


Name Address Sent Reply Received
B R JOSLIN 1 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
MR M GIBBS AND MS A BOLEMAN 63 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
MRS P A UPTON 112 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER MERLEY BARTON LANE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AX 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER GROUND FLOOR FLAT 61 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 86 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 88 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 90 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 92 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 94 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 98 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 100 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 102 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 104 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 106 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 108 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 110 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 114 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 116 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER CAKEBREAD BUNGALOW 71 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 96 SOUTH STREET BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AS 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER LITTLE HOMESTEAD BARTON LANE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AY 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER RETURNED BY ROYAL MAIL ON 8/3/12 'NO SUCH ADDRESS' 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 1 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 10 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 11 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 12 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 13 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 14 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 15 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 2 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 3 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 4 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 5 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 6 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 7 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 8 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 9 BARTON AVENUE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BA 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 1 VELATOR WAY BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2DD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 2 VELATOR WAY BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2DD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 3 VELATOR WAY BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2DD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 5 VELATOR WAY BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2DD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER VERTONIA SOUTH VIEW BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BB 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER BEECHFIELD SOUTH VIEW BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BB 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER VELATOR COTTAGE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BG 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER TREMOAT BARTON LANE BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2AX 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 5 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 10 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 13 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 14 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 15 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 16 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 17 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 18 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 19 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 20 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 21 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 22 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 23 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 24 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 25 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 38 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 45 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 46 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 47 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 48 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 53 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 54 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 55 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 56 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 57 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 58 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 59 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 60 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BD 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 61 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 62 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 64 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 65 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 66 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 67 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 68 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 69 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012
THE OWNER/OCCUPIER 73 PILL GARDENS BRAUNTON DEVON EX33 2BE 01/03/2012

Consultee List


Name Organisation Sent Reply Due Reply Received
Arboricultural Officer Arboricultural Officer 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
BRAUNTON ACCESS GROUP BRAUNTON ACCESS GROUP 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
British Telecom (Planning) British Telecom (Planning) 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT OFFICER COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT OFFICER 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
DCC - Childrens Services DCC - Childrens Services 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
DCC - Development Management Highways DCC - Development Management Highways 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 18/07/2012
Designing Out Crime Officer Designing Out Crime Officer 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 13/03/2012
Environment Agency Environment Agency 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 13/03/2012
Health & Social Care (Social services) Health & Social Care (Social services) 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
Housing Enabling Officer Housing Enabling Officer 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 20/04/2012
National Grid National Grid 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
Natural England Natural England 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 06/03/2012
NDC Waste, Recycling & Commercial Services NDC Waste, Recycling & Commercial Services 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
Open Space Officer Open Space Officer 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 29/03/2012
PARISH / TOWN COUNCIL PARISH / TOWN COUNCIL 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 15/03/2012
Planning Policy Unit Planning Policy Unit 29/02/2012 21/03/2012
South West Water South West Water 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 06/03/2012
Sustainability Officer Sustainability Officer 29/02/2012 21/03/2012 10/07/2012
WALES & WEST UTILITIES (GAS) WALES & WEST UTILITIES (GAS) 29/02/2012 21/03/2012

Constraints List


Constraints List
Advert Control
No associated appeals